Sewer vs. Septic on Your Finger Lakes Home – What You Need to Know

When we flush the toilet, everything magically disappears.  That is all we want to think about that.  If you are buying a house, the mechanicals are something to think about though.  If you are buying a house in The Finger Lakes, your plumbing may be connected to a public sewer system, or you might be on a septic system.  Day to day, you will not give that much thought.  The magic will happen.  Understanding what you are buying will be important.  You will want to know that it is functioning correctly. You also need to know what is required for maintenance.

SEWER

If you have always lived in an urban area, you have almost certainly been on a public sewer system.  The municipality will bill quarterly for connection to the sewer.  The cost may be tied to water usage and include a flat fee.  It’s not a major expense.  The municipality will maintain the sewer line at the road.  Everything on your property is your responsibility.  For long periods of time there may be no expenses for maintenance.  When they do happen, they can be quite costly.  As your sewer line gets old, it may develop cracks.  Tree roots can enter and plug it.  If things that are not supposed to be flushed get sent into your sewer line, that can cause a plug.  The fix is to have a plumber snake it.  They send a machine into your drain line that physically cuts through whatever is in there.  If you have a very long sewer line, you may encounter snaking difficulties. In this case, the next option is to send in a jetter.  A jetter will use a very high-pressure water cutter to do the same thing a snake would do.  If tree roots are getting into your sewer line, you may need to do this once or twice a year.  You may be able to continue an annual service for quite a while.  Eventually, the next step would be to replace the sewer line.  This means bringing in an excavator to dig it up and replace it.  It can become extremely expensive. Costs increase when it is necessary to remove large trees. Repairing concrete and driveways that are damaged in the process also adds to the expense.  Having the sewer pipe relined is also an option. That can be very expensive also.

 SEPTIC

A septic system accomplishes the same thing as a sewer line, but the magic is different.  You won’t get a bill from the municipality, but you will have a bill to have it pumped periodically. The first component of your traditional septic system is a large tank that is buried in the yard.  Anything that goes down the drain goes directly into that tank.  The tanks are usually between 750-2000 gallons. The size you need is usually measured by number of bedrooms (more bedrooms=more people= more waste).  Solids will settle to the bottom of the tank.  Liquid will overflow the tank. It will go into a distribution box. From there, liquid is sent into a leach field to drain into the yard. The leach field is usually four or five large diameter pipes with holes in them.  The field spreads over a large patch of your yard.  It is buried a couple feet deep and has a layer of sand and stone underneath.  Sometimes you can easily tell where the leach field is because the grass may be greener and grow faster there.  You need to know where your tank is and where your leach field is.  You can drive a lawn tractor and small equipment on your lawn. Make sure that nobody drives or parks cars on it. The weight can damage it.  You will have the tank pumped periodically to remove solids. This can be annually but usage will dictate that.  The day you have it pumped should not be the same day as your family picnic.  It’s going to smell for a few hours when they open that tank.  Some people use septic tabs. They are sold as helping the biology of your tank break down the solids.  DO NOT USE septic tabs. They cause the solids to break down just enough to create a muddy sludge that can clog your leach field.  Pumping the tank before it reaches capacity will need to be an important maintenance item.  Also, if you have a garbage disposal, try to limit how much volume you send down the drain.  Feed your garbage disposal snacks, not meals.  Never put grease, feminine hygiene products, or diapers into the drain. When the tank is pumped, those items will still be there.  Hopefully they did not make their way into your distribution box or leach field.  Not a good scenario. Avoid flushable wipes as well. Ensure only water, human waste, and vegetable material go into the drain.    If you regularly pump your tank, you should not need much other regular maintenance.

SEPTIC SYSTEM -AEROBIC

An aerobic system is similar in function to a traditional anaerobic system, but they are designed for unique use scenarios.  There are websites that will describe the science behind the differences between an aerobic and anaerobic system. This is not one of those websites. This is what you need to know when buying a house on a septic system.  An aerobic system is designed to be in a much smaller and maybe lesser accessible area.  The tank is smaller, and there is not a full-scale leach field. Oxygen is mechanically added to the system and churns the water. These systems are common on small lots where there is no room for a leach field. They are also used for houses very close to the waterline.  Maintenance is even more critical on these because the tanks are smaller. You will need to know the brand of your system and use a septic company that is certified to service that brand.  These are usually reliable systems. Problems can arise from overloading it though.  With a small lake house, the system will be designed to accommodate lite usage. Marketing a house for a short-term rental can cause problems. This happens when property owners allow more people than the system can accommodate to stay there.  If you purchase a small two-bedroom home, marketing it as sleeping eight people because there are two couches that have pull out beds is going to lead to very frequent maintenance and periodic problems.  Replacement of these systems may require people manually digging them in.  Excavators may not be able to get to the spot to dig.

PLUMBING

What can go down the drain has already been mentioned, but is worthy of additional commentary.  It does not matter if you are on a septic or sewer.  Some things should never go down the drain.  Grease will always cause problems. Foreign objects…’nuff said.  Flushable wipes need to be on this list.  Never use flushable wipes.  They always, always, always cause problems.  They are marketed as “flushable” because the toilet can force them into the drain.  They do not break down.  They get caught on things.  They can cause the drain to plug.  If you know a plumber, ask them.  They will confirm this for you. Drains getting snaked often come back with flushable wipes on the equipment because they are what caused the problem.  This product needs to be discontinued.

EITHER OR…

Either a septic system or a sewer line connection can serve your property well.  You need to know what you have. This allows you to plan for maintenance. It also helps you decide how closely you want to look at what is on the property. This is important as you decide if you are interested in a purchase.

To shop for lake houses in the beautiful Finger Lakes Region of New York State, explore available listings. Be sure to check them out at The Key to the Finger Lakes!

FLUSH ON…

Leave a Reply